رهپویه هنرهای نمایشی

رهپویه هنرهای نمایشی

فروکاست به‌مثابه ایدئولوژی نئولیبرال متأخر با ابتنا بر آرا بیونگ چول هان (مطالعه موردی فیلم در روزگار ما اثر هونگ سانگ سو)

نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی

نویسنده
گروه سینما، دانشکده هنر، دانشگاه سوره
چکیده
پژوهش حاضر با رویکردی انتقادی و با اتکا به آراء فیلسوف کره‌ای آلمانی معاصر، بیونگ-چول هان، به واکاوی مفهوم «فروکاست»به‌مثابه تجلیِ ایدئولوژی نئولیبرالیسم متأخر در فیلم «در روزگار ما»، می‌پردازد. مسئله اصلی پژوهش، تبیین چگونگیِ تقلیلِ مفاهیم بنیادین زیست‌جهان (نظیر زمان، روایت و تجربه) در عصر دیجیتال و بازنمایی این وضعیت در فرم و محتوای فیلم مورد بررسی است. در «جامعه دستیابی» که هان توصیف می‌کند، فشارهای انضباطی جای خود را به اجبارِ درونیِ «توانستن» داده‌اند و این تغییر پارادایم، منجر به ظهور پدیده‌هایی چون «شفافیت اجباری»، «گسست زمان روایی» و «فقر تجربه» شده است. این تحقیق با روش توصیفی-تحلیلی و بهره‌گیری از منابع کتابخانه‌ای، استدلال می‌کند که فیلم «در روزگار ما» نه صرفاً یک اثر هنری فاقد پیرنگ، بلکه آیینه‌ای تمام‌نما از بحران‌های وجودی سوژه مدرن است. یافته‌ها نشان می‌دهند که سانگ سو با حذف روایت کلاسیک و نمایشِ روزمرگی‌های تکراری و گسسته، «بحران روایت» را عینیت می‌بخشد؛ جایی که شخصیت‌ها نه در یک پیوستارِ تاریخی، بلکه در لحظاتِ آنیِ مصرف مانند غذا، الکل و حیوان خانگی زیست می‌کنند. تحلیل فیلم نشان می‌دهد که چگونه راز و فاصله به مثابه شروط حصول معنا جای خود را به شفافیت و پورنوگرافیِ اطلاعات داده‌اند و سوژه‌ها به جای تجربه عمیق، با انباشتی از رویدادهای گذرا مواجه‌اند.

این تحقیق با هدف تبیین چگونگی بازتولید این اندیشه‌ها در سینما و نمایش انسانِ "جامعه دستیابی" که از سوی هان توصیف شده، انجام شده است. روش تحقیق حاضر، کیفی و مبتنی بر رویکرد توصیفی-تحلیلی است که با مطالعه کتابخانه‌ای و الکترونیکی منابع مرتبط با نظریات هان و تحلیل فیلم «در روزگار ما» صورت پذیرفته است. نتیجه‌گیری پژوهش نشان می‌دهد که فیلم «در روزگار ما» نه یک نقد صریح، بلکه آینه‌ای تمام‌نما از وضعیت «فروکاست به مثابه ایدئولوژی» است. سانگ سو با رویکردی تساهل‌گرا، انسانی را تصویر می‌کند که در «جامعه دستیابی» فکر می‌کند آزاد است، اما در واقع در زندان یک نظام معنازدایانه گرفتار شده که در آن زبان از کارکرد آشکارگیِ حقیقت ساقط شده و به ابزاری برای روزمرگی تقلیل یافته است. بدین‌سان، اثر هنری به جای ایجاد تفاوت و رهایی به مکانیزمی برای عادی‌سازیِ استثمارِ روان و پذیرشِ زیستِ فاقدِ روایت بدل می‌گردد.
کلیدواژه‌ها
موضوعات

عنوان مقاله English

Reductionism as Late Neoliberal Ideology based on Byung Chul Han Views A Case Study of the Film In Our Day by Hong Sang soo

نویسنده English

Mahdi Khosravi dinarali
cinema Department, Faculty of Arts, Soore University
چکیده English

The present research undertakes a critical analysis to investigate the concept of reductionism as the manifestation of late neoliberal ideology within the cinematic structure of Hong Sang soo film In Our Day through the lens of the contemporary Korean German philosopher Byung Chul Han. The central problem of this study addresses the ontological crisis of the modern subject where fundamental concepts of the lifeworld such as time narrative and experience are systematically reduced. In the contemporary era which Han describes as the Achievement Society the disciplinary pressures of the past characterized by external prohibitions have given way to an internal compulsion of absolute capability. This paradigm shift has led to the emergence of phenomena such as forced transparency the fragmentation of narrative time and the poverty of experience. The primary objective is to elucidate how these philosophical concepts are reproduced in cinema and how the medium depicts the human of the achievement society who is constantly subject to various forms of reductionism under the guise of freedom.

The theoretical foundation of this research is built upon Byung Chul Han analysis of the transition from Michel Foucault Disciplinary Society to the Achievement Society. In the disciplinary model social order was maintained through negative prohibitions and institutions of confinement. In contrast the contemporary achievement society is defined by the modal verb can and positive reinforcements. Subjects are no longer obedient bodies but self optimizing entrepreneurs who voluntarily exploit themselves in the belief that they are realizing their freedom. Closely linked to this is the concept of Transparency and the loss of Distance. Han argues that modernity has stripped the human gaze of its depth replacing it with a compulsion for total visibility. The distinction between Eros and Pornography is crucial here. Eros thrives on distance mystery and the hidden whereas pornography demands immediate contact and total exposure. The transparency society reduces the world to accessible data eliminating the negativity of the Other and the mystery required for genuine meaning. Narrative requires a temporal continuity where the past present and future are woven into a meaningful whole.

This research employs a qualitative descriptive analytical method. The data collection is library based involving a close reading of Byung Chul Han philosophical corpus alongside related texts by Martin Heidegger and Louis Althusser. The analytical procedure involves a parallel examination of the theoretical concepts and the film In Our Day. The study decodes specific scenes dialogues and character behaviors to demonstrate how the philosophical abstractions of reductionism and the achievement society are materialized in cinematic form. The analysis focuses on the relationship between reductionism and ideology specifically interpreting ideology through the Althusserian lens not as false consciousness but as a structural force that interpellates individuals as subjects who misrecognize their subordination as autonomy.

The analysis of In Our Day reveals two parallel narratives that lack dramatic intersection and traditional development. The characters including an actress named Kim Min hee and an aging poet are thrown into spaces where they engage in mundane activities without teleological purpose. The film visually and narratively constructs the Crisis of Narration. The characters do not have a destiny in the Heideggerian sense but live in a state of drift. Their decisions are impulsive and contradictory exemplified by the poet vacillating attitude toward alcohol and tobacco. At one moment he refuses them for health reasons and the next he indulges in them based on the outcome of a rock paper scissors game. This reliance on chance and the immediate pleasure of consumption highlights the disintegration of narrative time. Life is reduced to a series of disjointed episodes where happiness is equated with fleeting moments of satisfaction rather than a sustained state of being.

The phenomenon of Transparency and the elimination of erotic distance is evident in the dialogue and interactions. The conversation about the actress cat serves as a pivotal moment where a character brutally links the memory of the pet to a sexual experience with a first boyfriend. This scene illustrates the pornographic nature of communication in the transparency society where nothing remains hidden and even intimate memories are stripped of their aura and reduced to explicit data. The film suggests that in a world where everything is exposed meaning evaporates and is replaced by a lingering sense of guilt or emptiness. Moreover the film portrays the Poverty of Experience through its repetitive structure. The characters go through motions that do not result in transformation. The experience is not a journey but a series of accumulated sensations.

The young aspiring actors seek guidance from the poet hoping for profound wisdom. However the poet advice acts as the ultimate manifestation of reductionism as ideology. He explicitly tells the student to stop looking for meaning claiming that seeking meaning is cowardly and that one should simply appreciate small things and dive into the water without thinking. This advice is not a spiritual liberation but a capitulation to the logic of the system. It encourages the subject to abandon critical thinking and historical awareness in favor of unreflective consumption of the present. By reducing truth to small accessible pleasures the poet reproduces the ideological demand of neoliberalism to be happy and productive subjects who do not question the structural void of their existence.

Drawing on Louis Althusser concept of interpellation the research demonstrates how the film depicts characters who have internalized the ideology of the achievement society. They are not coerced by an external dictator but are seduced by the idea of their own potential. They view their lifestyle choices their consumption habits and their professional pursuits as expressions of freedom. However this freedom is illusory. They are acting within a specific ideological framework that frames self exploitation as self realization. The ideology calls out to them saying You Can and they respond by constantly working on themselves even in their leisure time. The characters in the film are ostensibly free artists yet they are trapped in a cycle of mundane repetition and consumption unable to formulate a coherent narrative of their lives.

Language in the film plays a critical role in this process. Following Heidegger view that language is the house of being and Logos is that which reveals the research argues that the language used by the characters has been reduced. It no longer serves to reveal truth or foster deep understanding but functions as a tool for managing everydayness and justifying the status quo. When the poet dismisses the search for meaning he is using language to close off the possibility of transcendence. The dialogue becomes functional and flattened mirroring the smooth surface of the digital world described by Han. The characters inability to narrate their own lives coherently is a linguistic failure caused by the ideological reduction of their world to a collection of consumable items and data points.

The study concludes that In Our Day is not merely a minimalist depiction of life but a profound sociological document that mirrors the condition of Reductionism as Ideology. The findings indicate that the crisis of narration mandatory transparency the rupture of temporality and the poverty of experience are not just abstract concepts but constitute the lived reality of the film characters. The film illustrates the transition from the disciplinary subject to the achievement subject who replaces the negativity of prohibition with the positivity of capability yet ends up in a state of depressive hedonism. Hong Sang soo approach is characterized by a form of tolerance that does not explicitly critique this ideology but presents it as the inevitable texture of reality. By portraying the emptiness of the characters lives without dramatic judgment the film invites the viewer to gaze upon the nakedness of existence in the achievement society.

The characters reduction of meaning to momentary consumption is presented as a coping mechanism. The poet philosophy of enjoying small things is exposed as an ideological tool that masks the lack of genuine narrative and historical agency. Ultimately the research asserts that the film demonstrates how late neoliberal ideology operates not through deception but through the reduction of the human subject to a transparent data generating entity. The elimination of the Other and the removal of distance result in a Hell of the Same where individuals are trapped in a feedback loop of their own desires and anxieties. The film reflects a world where the capacity for deep transformative experience has been atrophied leaving behind a landscape of atomized time and superficial connections. This cinematic representation confirms Byung Chul Han diagnosis that in the age of digital psychopolitics the greatest threat to human freedom is not external oppression but the internal voluntary erosion of the self capability to narrate a meaningful life. The reductionism analyzed in this film is the defining ideological feature of our time turning the rich complexity of the lifeworld into a flat searchable and consumable database where the human subject is reduced to a user and life is reduced to a feed.

کلیدواژه‌ها English

Cinema
Achievement society
Temporality
Crisis of Narration
Poverty of Experience
Byung-Chul Han

مقالات آماده انتشار، پذیرفته شده
انتشار آنلاین از 19 خرداد 1405

  • تاریخ دریافت 14 آذر 1404
  • تاریخ بازنگری 07 خرداد 1405
  • تاریخ پذیرش 19 خرداد 1405