Rahpooye Honar/Performing Arts

Rahpooye Honar/Performing Arts

A Comprehensive Analysis of the Literary and Dramatic Features of the Ta’ziyeh of Imam Reza (PBUH) by Rajaei Zafarehei (Based on Manuscript No. 11002 of the University of Tehran)

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
1 PhD in Persian Language and Literature, Faculty of Letters and Humanities, University of Shiraz, Iran
2 Associate Professor, Department of Persian Language and Literature, Faculty of Letters and Humanities, University of Shiraz, Iran
Abstract
In the Islamic period, with the prevalence of writing Maqtal, which was mainly about the events of Ashura, the tradition of composing and writing ritual works continued, and later in the ninth century, with the book Rawda al-Shuhada by Kashefi, it reached its peak and even surpassed the works written after it. It should be noted that the attention of political authorities to Ta’ziyeh from the Safavids to the end of the Pahlavis was accompanied by ups and downs. The roots of ritual performances are repeatedly mentioned in literary chronicles, and usually the common proposition among them is that ritual performances in the general sense in Iran go back to centuries before Islam. If Ta’ziyeh is not initially considered a ritual performance, the continuation of Ta’ziyeh in its non-Islamic and general sense can be traced back to centuries before Islam and, in its specific meaning in the Islamic era, at least in a specific way, to the first century of the Hijri lunar calendar. Of course, Ta’ziyeh, in the form that can be called a performance today, far from being considered a mere ritual, is not very old according to some researchers and dates back to the era of Karim Khan Zand and ultimately the Safavids. On the other hand, the definitions of Ta’ziyeh found in various sources usually consider it to be a type of Iranian-Shiite performance whose content, regardless of the methods of processing the structure, is based on religious teachings. Ta’ziyeh is important not only from historical-social and literary-performance perspectives but also, since it narrates about a specific religion, it also represents a type of ritual and religion. From the perspective of literary types, it can also be claimed that Ta’ziyeh is one of the main sub-genres of Shiite literature, which has been popular among the Iranian masses, especially since the end of the Safavid era, due to its importance in dramatic literature. This importance and social status have caused many orators and poets associated with the masses, especially since the Qajar era, to create numerous texts on the subject of the martyrdom of the Ahl al-Bayt and their lives (PBUT) in the form of poetic plays. Many of these works have been recorded in manuscripts and have received less attention in the course of dramatic art. On the other hand, the existing manuscripts of Ta’ziyeh and parallel research in the field of Ta’ziyeh studies generally focus on the tragedy of Karbala, and less attention has been paid to other topics such as the tragedies of other Imams (PBUT). Mohammad Ali Rajaei Zafarehei (1281 AH-1361 AH) is one of the prominent religious poets of the late Qajar and early Pahlavi eras. He composed numerous works in the field of Ta’ziyeh, and despite his literary position in the field of Ta’ziyeh, his works have been less introduced and published. Accordingly, in the present study, based on one of his lesser-known Ta’ziyehs in mourning for Imam Reza (PBUH), an attempt has been made to discover missing links in the research on the history of Ta’ziyeh during the middle of his lifetime, and in the process, some literary features of this influential literary genre are introduced by analyzing Rajaei Zafarehei’s work as a perfect example of literary Ta’ziyehs of the late Qajar era. To achieve this goal, after a general study of Ta’ziyeh, the text of Rajaei Zafarehei’s Ta’ziyeh has been analyzed in detail in two areas: literary features and dramatic elements using the method of content analysis. The most important results that can be obtained from this study are that, in comparison to many poets of the Qajar era, Rajaei Zafarehei has tried not to limit himself to expressing moods and imaginations in this work and his other compositions and has been able to display various aspects of Shiite identity through narrations and dialogues. One of the most important manifestations of his effort is the use of content-related and structural strategies to give the supporters an advantage over the opponents. It seems that the main difference between Ta’ziyeh as a native type of play and Western play is more related to the arrangement and editing of content, and generally the differences between the two have not been related to formal structures. It can also be analyzed that the greater attention paid to topics related to the tragedy of Karbala in Ta’ziyeh is probably due to the greater poignancy of that event in terms of the magnitude of the subject matter, as the Shiite world still holds Muharram more dear than other days of mourning. Obviously, this does not mean lowering the status of any of the Ahl al-Bayt (PBUT) in the art of Ta’ziyeh. Perhaps it is because of the sacred view of the characters in Ta’ziyeh that the kind of sophistication that is seen in the characterization of the characters in Western works is not very tangible in Ta’ziyeh. This is probably because in Western drama, the poet’s goal is generally to elevate the dramatic art of the work, while in Ta’ziyeh, since the main goal of the poet is to mention the tragedy and express completely religious and heavenly themes, he does not prioritize the artistic issues of the play and does not pay attention to the formal characteristics of the play and its art. This issue also shines outside of the play in the poetic techniques of Ta’ziyeh, so much so that Rajaei Zafarehei’s version, despite his poetic concern for the order of the play, cannot be considered among the first-rate brilliant works of the Qajar era in terms of literary grandeur, although its various valuable literary and non-literary aspects indicate the importance of the Ta’ziyeh’s position. The final point is that Rajaei Zafarehei’s Ta’ziyeh sheds light on one of the neglected aspects of Shiite dramatic literature for the audience. The importance of Imam Reza’s (PBUH) Ta’ziyeh and the relative strength of this work in comparison to other Ta’ziyehs on the same subject are some of the points that we have reached through this research.
It should also be said that Rajaei Zafarehei’s Ta’ziyeh, in addition to its relative literary strength, also has capabilities from the perspective of dramatic elements that have received less attention. The final finding is that, due to his mastery of literary principles, unlike many Qajar era Ta’ziyeh writers, he insists on observing literary standards in his poems. He has included three components of impact on the audience, attention to the religious content prevalent in the era, and observance of general literary features such as meter and rhyme as the principles of his Ta’ziyeh art and has tried to create a relative diversity in the field of meters and musical elements of speech; however, the difference in the dramatic field in his work from the style of modern plays on the one hand, and the religious concern in observing relvigious meanings in his works have caused that, from a literary perspective, his works cannot be placed at the forefront of Iranian dramatic literature of the last two hundred years. Despite all these points, one of the main findings in the study of his Ta’ziyeh’s is the necessity of introducing and publishing his gatherings as works in the transition from traditional dramatic art to the contemporary era.
Keywords
Subjects

·         Asadzadeh, Dariush. (2010). A Survey of the History of Iranian Theater, Tehran: Avardgah-e Honar va Andisheh. [in Persian]
·         Azizi, Mahmoud. (2009a, Spring). Ta`zia from the Perspective of Orientalists, Tehran: Iranian Academy of the Arts – Matn Publications. [in Persian]
·         Azizi, Mahmoud. (2009b, Summer). The Christian Maiden: An Examination of the Views of Certain Contemporary Theater Theorists and a Comparison with Ta`zia, Tehran: Iranian Academy of the Arts – Matn Publications. [in Persian]
·         Bayhaqi, Abolfazl. (2013). History of Mas'udi: History of Bayhaqi, 3 vols. Edited by Khalil Khatib-Rahbar, Tehran: Mahtab. [in Persian]
·         Bolukbashi, Ali. (2011). Reading Ta`zia, Tehran: Amirkabir. [in Persian]
·         Dehghani, Hossein. (2008). Ta`zia in Bushehr, Tehran: Tolo Danesh. [in Persian]
·         Esmaeili, Hossein. (1995). An Introduction to the Typology of Ta`zia, Cinema Theater, Vol. 2, No. 9, Bahman, pp. 79–85. [in Persian]
·         Fathali Beigi, Davud. (1991). The Corner in Ta`zia, Theater Season. Issue 14, pp. 229-272. [in Persian]
·         Fathali Beigi, Davud. (1995 and 1996). Fundamentals of Farce in Traditional Drama, Art, Issue 30, Winter and Spring, pp. 343-350. [in Persian]
·         Fathali Beigi, Davud. (2002). Thematic Index of Ta`zia, Theater, Issues 31, 32 and 33, Summer and Autumn and Winter, pp. 80-119. [in Persian]
·         Hafez, Shams al-Din Mohammad. (1993). Divan, With the efforts of Khalil Khatib-Rehbar, Tehran: Safi Ali Shah. [in Persian]
·         Homayuni, Sadegh. (1998). Shiraz, the Origin of Ta`zia, Shiraz: Persian Studies Foundation. [in Persian]
·         Homayuni, Sadegh. (n.d). Ta`zia and Ta`zia Reading, n.w: A Celebration of Art. [in Persian]
·         Homayuni, Jalal-eddin. (2009). Rhetoric Techniques and Literary Crafts, Tehran: Ahura. [in Persian]
·         Karami, Mohammad Hossein. (2009). Prosody and Rhyme in Persian Poetry, Shiraz: Shiraz University. [in Persian]
·         Kazan, Thaddeus (1991). Sign in Theater: An Introduction to the Semiology of the Performing Arts, Translated by Naghme Samini, Bidar, No. 12, February, pp. 29-42. [in Persian]
·         Kouchakzadeh, Reza. (2014). A Comparative Study of Two Similes of the Martyrdom of Imam Reza (PBUH), Comparative Art Studies. Year 4. Issue 8. Autumn and Winter. pp. 123-134. [in Persian]
·         Mirjahani Tabatabaei, Seyyed Mohammad Hassan. (2007). Crying for Hussein (PBUH). Research by Ruhollah Abbasi, Qom: Resalat. [in Persian]
·         Naser Bakht, Mohammad Hossein. (1999). Dervish Curtains: The Art of Curtain Reading and Painting Dervish Curtains, Art, No. 35, pp. 102-114. [in Persian]
·         Naser Bakht, Mohammad Hossein. (2001-2002). Functions and Duties of the Imitator, Theater, No. 29-30, Winter and Spring, pp. 211-248. [in Persian]
·         Naser Bakht, Mohammad Hossein. (2024). Ta`zia (Imitator Reading), a Sacred Drama?, Rahpooiyeh Hekmat Honar, Volume 3, No. 2 (5 in a row), Autumn and Winter, pp. 27-37. [in Persian]
·         Nasri Ashrafi, Jahangir and Abbas Shirzadi Ahudashti. (2009). History of Iranian Art. 2 vols. Tehran: Arvan. [in Persian]
·         Omrani, Seyyed Abolhassan. (2012). A brief perspective on the relationship between Ta`zia and television, Shiraz: Navid Shiraz. [in Persian]
·         Pahlavan, Keyvan. (2014). Tehran Province: Oral Culture in Iranian Music, Tehran: Aron. [in Persian]
·         Rajaee Zafrae, Mohammad Ali. (2011). Ta`zia Performances, Manuscript held at the Central Library and Documentation Center of the University of Tehran (Digital Section, Book No. 11002); transcribed from a version dated Sha‘ban 1343 AH, in the handwriting of Mohammad Hasan Rajaee Zafrae. [in Persian]
·         Razi, Shams Qays. (1935). Al-Mu‘jam fī Ma‘āyīr Ash‘ār al-‘Ajam, Edited by Mohammad Qazvini; collated by Modarres Razavi, Tehran: Khavar. [in Persian]
·         Salehi-Rad, Hasan. (2010). Ta`zia Performances, 2 vols. Tehran: Soroush. [in Persian]
·         Samini, Naghmeh. (1993). The Influence of the Structure of Religious Performance on Iranian Cinema, Binab: Essays on Culture and Art, No. 2, August and September, pp. 194-205. [in Persian]
·         Shahidi, Enayatollah. (2001–2002). Haj Mirza Aghasi’s Tekyeh, Theater, Issues 29 & 30 (Winter & Spring), pp. 158–173. [in Persian]
·         Taghian, Laleh. (1991). Iranian Ta`zia: Performance or Ritual?, Theater, No. 14, pp. 33–55. [in Persian]
·         Taghian, Laleh. (1995). On Ta`zia and Theater in Iran, Tehran: Markaz. [in Persian]
·         Taghian, Laleh. (1992). Ta`zia: A Traditional, Philosophical, Mystical, and Religious Ritual, Book of the Month of Art, No. 53-54, February and March, pp. 10-13. [in Persian]
 

  • Receive Date 31 October 2025
  • Revise Date 21 November 2025
  • Accept Date 01 December 2025